Claim Denial – M10

Introduction

Medical billing professionals face numerous challenges when handling Medicare regulations for Durable Medical Equipment (DME). Following proper procedures directly affects reimbursement success and payment timelines. Among the various codes that medical billers must understand, M-codes serve a distinct purpose in communicating specific billing conditions to Medicare. This article examines the M10 modifier code, explaining its meaning, application, and impact on the billing process for medical equipment.

1. What is the M10 Modifier?

The M10 modifier code indicates: “Equipment purchases are limited to the first or the tenth month of medical necessity.”

The M10 modifier is used to let Medicare and other insurers know that durable medical equipment (DME) is being purchased within the allowed time period as per Medicare rules. It confirms that the timing of the equipment purchase follows Medicare’s specific guidelines.

How M10 Works in DME Billing

Medicare uses a “capped rental” approach for many DME items. Medicare pays monthly rental fees for the equipment in this approach.  Medicare allows the purchase only during the specified timeline for many items:

  1. The first month of service (immediate purchase)
  2. The tenth month of service (after substantial rental period)

Common Equipment Types Where M10 Applies

M10 modifier usage is particularly relevant for these DME categories:

  • Wheelchairs and mobility devices
  • Hospital beds
  • Patient lifts
  • Support surfaces
  • Nebulizers
  • Traction equipment

Each equipment category follows specific Medicare guidelines regarding which items qualify for first or tenth month purchase options.

DME Categories and M10 Application

Equipment Type

First Month Purchase?

Tenth Month Purchase?

Special Considerations

Wheelchairs (Standard)

Yes

Yes

Power options often require rental first

Hospital Beds

No

Yes

Only after rental period

Patient Lifts

Yes

Yes

Weight capacity affects eligibility

Nebulizers

Yes

Rarely needed

Often less expensive to purchase initially

Support Surfaces

Varies by type

Yes

Group 2 & 3 surfaces have specific rules

Walkers

Yes

Rarely needed

Usually purchased in first month

Distinguishing M10 from M9

While this article focuses on M10, it’s worth noting how it differs from the related M9 modifier. M9 indicates: “The ‘purchase price’ of the item has been paid. Rental payments have already been applied to the purchase price.” Unlike M10, which addresses timing restrictions, M9 deals with applied rental payments.

Feature

M10 Modifier

M9 Modifier

Definition

“Equipment purchases limited to 1st or 10th month of medical necessity”

“Rental payments applied toward purchase price”

Primary Focus

Timing restriction on when purchases can occur

Financial application of prior payments

Used When

Purchasing equipment at specific timeline points

Converting rental to purchase with credits

Calculation Required

No

Yes

Documentation Needed

Proof of timing (1st or 10th month)

Payment history, rental records

Common Error

Attempting purchase outside allowed timeframes

Failing to subtract rental payments

2. Billing Challenges with M10

Medical billing professionals face certain challenges when they handle the  claims that involve the M10 modifier, such as:

1. Timing Verification

Accurately mentioning whether the equipment is truly in its first or tenth month of medical need can be difficult , specially if:

  • There were gaps in medical necessity
  • The patient switched providers
  • Prior authorization dates differ from delivery dates

2. Documentation Requirements

Medicare requires specific documentation showing:

  • Start date of medical necessity
  • Continuous need through present date (for 10th month purchases)
  • Proper count of rental months
  • Evidence that the current month is indeed the 1st or 10th (Incomplete documentation can cause claim denials or payment delays.)

3. Provider Communication Issues

Physicians may not understand the timing restrictions, leading to:

  • Requests for purchases outside allowable windows
  • Insufficient documentation of continued necessity
  • Missing documentation of original start date

4. Patient Confusion

Patients sometimes don’t understand the purchase timing restrictions, forming challenges when they:

  • Request purchase during non-eligible months
  • Question why purchase can’t occur in other months
  • Don’t understand why timing matters for reimbursement

COMMON M-10 BILLING CHALLENGES

Timing Verification – 35%

Documentation Issues – 30% 

Provider Communication – 20%

Patient Confusion – 15%

3. Financial Impact of M10 Application

When applied correctly, the M10 modifier has significant financial implications for both providers and patients:

For Providers:

  • Reduced claim denials related to purchase timing
  • Faster payment processing for properly timed purchases
  • More predictable revenue cycles
  • Lower administrative costs from avoided resubmissions

For Patients:

  • Better ability to plan for equipment ownership
  • Clearer understanding of purchase options
  • Buying equipment at the right time may help lower the amount patients need to pay themselves.

4. Best Practices for M10 Modifier Usage

Medical billing departments can improve their success rates with M10 claims by following these recommendations:

Implement Tracking Systems

Create reliable methods to track:

  • Initial date of medical necessity
  • Monthly rental periods
  • Approaching 10th month milestones
  • Documentation expiration dates

Set up automatic alerts to inform staff when durable medical equipment qualifies for purchase using the M10 modifier.

Staff Education

Provide specialized training on:

  • Medicare’s purchase timing rules
  • Proper documentation of month count
  • Verification processes for 1st/10th month status
  • Common denial reasons for M10 claims

Provider Education

Develop simple guides for referring physicians explaining:

  • The importance of documenting initial need date
  • Requirements for continued necessity documentation
  • Why purchases can happen only  in 1st or 10th month
  • Documentation needed to support M10 claims

Patient Communication Strategies

Create clear patient materials explaining:

  • When purchase options become available
  • Why timing restrictions exist
  • Planning for equipment ownership
  • Documentation they need to maintain

5. Real-World Example

First Month Purchase Scenario:

Medical Supply Company A received a physician’s order for a standard manual wheelchair for a Medicare beneficiary. The physician documented that the patient needed the wheelchair permanently rather than temporarily.

Actions taken:

  • Verified the patient had not previously rented this equipment
  • Confirmed this was genuinely the first month of medical necessity
  • Applied the M10 modifier to the purchase claim
  • Included documentation of initial medical necessity
  • Submitted claim with the HCPCS code K0001 and M10 modifier

Result: Medicare processed and paid the claim within 14 days, recognizing the legitimate first-month purchase with the M10 modifier.

Tenth Month Purchase Scenario:

Medical Supply Company B had been providing a hospital bed (HCPCS E0260) to a patient for nine consecutive rental months. As the tenth month approached:

Actions taken:

  • Reviewed rental history to confirm this was genuinely the tenth month
  • Obtained updated documentation of continued medical necessity
  • Applied the M10 modifier to the purchase claim
  • Included documentation showing rental months 1-9 and current 10th month
  • Added remarks clarifying “10th month purchase per Medicare guidelines”

Result: The claim was approved, and ownership of the hospital bed transferred to the patient.

Contrasting Error Scenario:

Medical Supply Company C attempted to bill for the purchase of a patient lift in the sixth month of rental:

Actions taken:

  • Applied M10 modifier despite not being 1st or 10th month
  • Submitted claim for purchase price
  • Included documentation of continued need

Result: Claim denied with reason code indicating “purchase not allowed in month 6 – only in month 1 or 10”

Success Rates with Proper M10 Application

FIRST-PASS CLAIM SUCCESS RATES

  • With proper M10 usage: 94%
  • Without M10 (when needed): 46%
  • Incorrect month with M10: 21%

6. M10 and Audit Prevention

The M10 modifier often receives special attention during Medicare audits due to its specific timing requirements. Properly documenting  M10 claims can help in strong audit protection. Key audit defense elements include:

  1. Clear timeframe Documentation: Records that shows exact start date and month count
  2. Verification Process: Documentation of how 1st/10th month status was verified
  3. Physician Support: Clear medical records establishing initial and ongoing need
  4. Consistent Application: Evidence of systematic application of M10 only in appropriate months

Audit Risk Analysis

Scenario

Low Risk

Medium Risk

High Risk

Proper M10 + Documentation

94%

5%

1%

M10 with Partial Docs

40%

50%

10%

No M10 (when required)

15%

35%

50%

Wrong Month with M10

5%

25%

70%

7. Medicare Compliance and M10

While Medicare’s rules for the timing of DME purchases are persistent , they must be followed carefully. The M10 modifier supports billing experts stay flexible by:

  1. Documenting adherence to purchase timing restrictions
  2. Supporting proper billing practices for equipment acquisition
  3. Providing clear signals to Medicare about purchase timing
  4. Preventing improper purchasing attempts outside allowed timeframes

Medicare Policy Key Points for M10

MEDICARE DME PURCHASE POLICY KEY POINTS – 

  • Capped rental items default to rental unless purchase is allowed
  • First month purchase option applies to limited DME categories
  • Tenth month purchase represents standard purchase option
  • Some items never qualify for purchase (oxygen equipment)
  • Power mobility devices follow separate purchase guidelines
  • Patient must maintain medical necessity through purchase month

8. Regional Variations in M10 Application

Even though M10 guidelines are standardized across the country, the way they’re understood and handled can differ between Medicare Administrative Contractor (MAC) regions. Being aware of these regional differences can help reduce claim denials when working across different areas.

Regional Claim Approval Rates with M10

MAC Region

First-Pass Approval Rate

Secondary Documentation Rate

Northeast

93%

6%

Southeast

89%

10%

Midwest

95%

4%

Southwest

91%

8%

West

92%

7%

Conclusion

The M10 modifier plays an important role in DME billing, particularly in relation to the timing of equipment purchases. If used properly, it allows medical billing experts to:

  • Document compliance with Medicare’s purchase timing restrictions
  • Avoid claim denials related to improper purchase timing
  • Support transparent communication about purchase eligibility
  • Reduce payment delays and improve cash flow

For billing departments, understanding when and how to use the M10 modifier represents an opportunity to improve operational efficiency and financial performance. proper tracking systems, complete documentation protocols, and careful verification processes all lead to successful M10 application.

By mastering the specific timing requirements associated with M10, medical practices and supply companies can enhance their reimbursement rates while maintaining full compliance with Medicare regulations.

 

Starting a clinic does not have to be difficult

Schedule a 1:1 with a startup specialist to see how we can help you